This latter explanation might be supported by the cracks in the inner walls Bruno has been repairing while in hiding. She blamed Alma for the miracle dying and said their relatives' pain was her fault. She was small when these ceremonies took place, a child, and she didn't do anything wrong. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. However, Disney has also made its latest magical offering available in viewers homes. Both sisters are mutually jealous of each other's lives, which differed from their own; Isabela envying Mirabel being unburdened by expectations and free to do whatever she wants. However, there may be a reason why Abuela didn't like her. when alma was setting the example that it was okay to be rude and dismissive of mirabel and her feelings, isa would've followed the cause of that resentment back to its roots, in the service of preventing alma's ire from being turned on herself. Try This Nicolas Cage Movie Instead, Flyana Bosss Viral Fame Is Changing the Way People See Running Scenes, The Self-Indulgence of And Just Like That Is Becoming Incredibly Tiresome, 'Dimension 20: Dungeons and Drag Queens' Is the Most Unexpectedly Delightful Show of 2023, A Sea of White: A Kristen Bell Snap Becomes a Meme (Again), All 'Walking Dead' Spin Offs Ranked Worst to Best. Encanto is a unique story about a family that shows the consequences of the pressure to perform. Isabela Madrigal is one of the main characters of Disney's 2021 animated feature film, Encanto. Encanto: 10 Things About Mirabel That Make No Sense - Screen Rant After finding the vision in the cave beyond the chasm, Mirabel is forced to flee a deluge of sand. the resentment falls away, and they're laughing and having fun together - possibly like how they were before mirabel's gift ceremony? Obviously, the whole family is troubled by Bruno's dark visions: They sing an entire song about why they don't even talk about him in passing. Enjoyed this? If studios are going to continue to explore complex family dynamics, there needs to be some sort of conversation about the fact that you don't need to forgive toxic family members just because they are family. Cookie Notice with mirabel and her perceived failure, alma likely went into a paranoid frenzy - maybe this was around the time that her insistence that the family work twice as hard, in order to keep the magic strong came into the picture? They use their gifts, such as healing and super strength, for good to help their neighbors. I don't understand why people hate Abuela Alma. she's sad and quiet, after alma discovers them rather than angry and actively frightened - almost like she's resigning herself to no longer being alma's favourite and therefore giving up her own access to alma's love. answer the question why does abuela hate mirabel, which will help you get the most accurate answer. The Encanto Fan Theory That Explains Why Mirabel Didn't Get A Gift What you're saying makes next to no sense. All rights reserved. SPOILER I think what really cut deep was NOT the fact that Abuela blamed everything on Mirabel. Since Mirabel is becoming the family leader, it makes sense that she wouldn't have a gift. A miracle happens in the wake of this tragedy: The candle she's carrying gains a mystical design, and proceeds to build a sentient house (the Casita) for her to live in, within a lush valley. For all the joy in the Casita, there's a lot of silence, too. It's time to experience the magic! Mirabel spends the entire movie trying to figure out its mysterious nature, but only finds a cryptic vision from her uncle Bruno of herself in front of a badly damaged Casita. How does she get down? And if she's really destined for a permanent lack of gift, why can't her loving house do her a solid and move her out of the nursery, at the very least? To cosplay or not to cosplay? As the movie goes on and the magic begins to fade. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. She is the eldest daughter of Julieta and Agustn, as well as the older sister of Mirabel and Luisa and the eldest granddaughter of Pedro. It makes a point of only vaguely explaining its various magical happenings, allowing viewers to draw their own conclusions. The protagonist of Encanto is Mirabel ( Stephanie Beatriz), the youngest member of the Madrigal family, a family whose children have been blessed by a miracle that created a living house and gave. However, 10 years prior to the events of the story, granddaughter Mirabel mysteriouslydoesn'treceive a gift. The theory about Mirabel's lack ofgifts has a lot of evidence. Encanto may not have a villain but, to many, Abuela comes awfully close. For instance, though the family starts to lose their gifts in the film, the magical abilities come back by the end, and the village helps to repair their magical house. We just have to accept that Alma knows it was her fault we don't understand, at any point, exactly how her emotional state causes issues with the miracle. Everything is fine now, forgiveness given, but the message that you need to forgive family for being toxic because they are family is not a good one. Why bring the magic back at all if not to address the mystery of what her power is? Mirabel may not have a gift like her family, but by not having one, she was able to show the family's most powerful member that things need to change. She is the youngest daughter of Julieta and Agustn Madrigal and youngest sister of Isabela and Luisa, who has the distinction of . Abuela and Mirabel didn't see eye to eye at the beginning of Encanto, and here's why. Everyone in the Madrigal family gained amagical gift when they turned five years old. Brunos situation is so painfully tragic, and John Leguizamo does a great job in the role. ", More:Wild Encanto Theory Perfectly Explains Vin Diesel's Fast & Furious Powers. Published Jan 13, 2022 Encanto deals with the pressures of family life in many ways, but one theory shows how Mirabel's lack of powers represents a tragic lesson. I also like that Mabel and the rest of the GF characters are flawed because it makes them feel real. But this doesn't make it any less frustrating to watch her pretend not to believe Mirabel about seeing cracks appear in the Casita during Antonio's gift celebration. Alma is not a narcissist or an abusive figure. They both want the other's life. Children make more selfish mistakes than adults. The first trailer, poster, and high-quality images for Warner Bros. other Christmas musical, Wonka, have been released. It seems, for a moment, as though everyone's powers are truly gone, and that this might be okay. Leaving things vague puts more emphasis on the magical elements of the story, which in turn highlights the familial bond that is the movie's core. RELATED: Encanto: 5 Gifts No One Would Want In Real Life (& 5 That'd Be Useful). G. C. By Courtney Mason Published Feb 26, 2022 Abuela's past trauma made her harsh on her family, especially so on Mirabel. Mirabel Madrigal is the protagonist of Disney's 2021 animated feature film Encanto. He's done everything from unearthing the discarded Game of Thrones pilot script in a library in Texas to finding out why Steve left Blue's Clues. The chief conflict in "Encanto" is the clash between Mirabel's desire to understand what's happening to the miracle and Alma's desperation to ignore the issue entirely, out of devastating anxiety. Some people also complain that Mabel hasn't . 35 JulyOfAugust 2 yr. ago Isabella and Mirabel are both jealous of each other, Mirabel is jealous of Isabella place in the family and Isabella is jealous of Mirabel's freedom. alma could've pressured isa to be even more perfect than she already was, in explicit response to mirabel seemingly letting the family down. Mirabel didn't get a gift, and her family hasn't really treated her the same way since. in which case, isabela would've grown up with the majority of alma's positive attention, and likely would've been by alma's side for a disproportionately large amount of her life. The only thing that he knew was that the fate of the Madrigalswould be up to his niece, putting a burden on Mirabel's shoulders. If your parents or siblings or anyone has hurt you, you are not under any obligation to forgive them for their transgressions because they are family. His family treated him terribly because they didn't like the outcome of his visions. Being the first grandchild of the Madrigals, she is described as the "golden child" of the . Yes she has made selfish mistakes and choices before, but there's a big difference between the two. However, everyone saw his visions as curses, and it got so bad that Bruno vanished one day. this results in isabela getting the majority of alma's love and attention, where luisa is taken for granted and mirabel is the family scapegoat. Pedro was killed, but in Almas grief and with his sacrifice, a miracle happed with a magical candle that protected Alma and the rest of the people fleeing. Alma lashes out more and more until it is said that the way she is treating Mirabel is the reason the magic is fading. Encantofocuses on the Madrigal family, who each possess magical gifts, and the dynamics of their extended family as they celebrate their magic and Columbian culture. This complex and ambiguous nature hasn't kept "Encanto" from becoming a smash hit. She did that for 50 WHOLE YEARS and the only issue was that she got too overzealous and tried to compensate a bit too much. which makes alma and isa's irritation towards mirabel unfair opposition that mira did not deserve. Isabela Madrigal | Encanto Wiki | Fandom The candle, Mirabel's dress, and her uncle Bruno's vision feature a butterfly. She does not possess a magical gift, unlike the rest of her family. it wouldn't be a stretch to say that alma was the main instigator between isabela and mirabel's resentment because of her constant labelling of isa as the golden child and mira as the mistake, with her own love being the gatekeeping force that drove a wedge between the sisters. Kristen is also known to be very passionate about her role and the GF fans. Disney's Encanto Wins Golden Globe For Best Animated Film, Beauty And The Beast's Darkest Theory Turns The Disney Film Into Pure Horror, Disney's Treatment Of Pixar Is Getting Weird. Cookie Notice Small items of technology, including an old-fashioned camera and a sewing machine, might place it around the beginning of the 20th century. Mirabel didn't get a gift, but the way Alma speaks about it, it makes it seem like Mirabel did something wrong. Pedro Madrigal | Disney Wiki | Fandom TheFamily Madrigalis still magical, and the village remains in a Madrigal-made protection bubble. Sand blows everywhere. All rights reserved. He is the late patriarch of the Madrigal family, husband of Alma Madrigal, father of triplets Julieta, Pepa and Bruno, and the grandfather of Isabela, Dolores, Luisa, Camilo, Mirabel, and Antonio. As that becomes the new goal, we get more insight into the generational trauma and perfectionism that has plagued the family. I got to take part in an early press day forEncanto back in September, and when Disney asked for my feedback, my response to the 35 minutes of footage I saw was, "was I supposed to hate the grandma?" RELATED: 10 Encanto Fan Theories (According To Reddit). **Spoilers for Encanto, streaming now on Disney+.**. Mirabel Madrigal - Wikipedia Mirabel confronted her sister, Luisa, about what was going on with the magic, as she was one of the few people that knewsomething was wrong. When their "miracle" begins to fade, Mirabel takes . The storyline revolves around the Madrigal family and their inner dispute, and at the center of the conflict lies Abuela Alma, the family matriarch. I get it. Pedro Madrigal is a minor character in the 2021 Disney animated film Encanto. This and the latest casing rumors indicate this movie will be buckwild. All rights reserved. Of course, the potentialEncanto theory also takes several leaps. The Biggest Unanswered Questions In Encanto. As explainedin a fan theory (via Reddit), Mirabel was supposed to lead the village into the modern world. The implication is that she has forgiven him for abandoning her, and that is why he was able to pass on. Updated Apr 18, 2023 Encanto's Mirabel is the only ungifted Madrigal. Does Luisa's room have massive things to help her hone her strength? "Encanto" mines a lot of drama from the sight of the Casita being consumed by these mysterious cracks, but their inconsistency and the confusing nature of the Casita itself makes it hard to know how much of a threat the Madrigals truly face. Sadly the reason why she was cold towards Mirabel was because of what she reminded her of, the fact that their Encanto might end someday. Alma goes to find her and apologizes for the way she has treated Mirabel, and everything is apparently fine. Despite being framed as a troublemaker, everything he does is for the betterment of his loved ones. Like in the case of many Disney movies, the plot of Encanto kicks off with a song. The catchiest song in the movie is "We Don't Talk About Bruno" because no one even wants to talk about him, and Bruno knows it because he is seeing it all through the cracks in the walls. Answer (1 of 5): The most common reason I've seen people dislike Mabel is that she is selfish. Seeing Isabela and Mirabel together, Abuela Alma is furious. Nicholas Brooks has been writing professionally for over a decade, covering many aspects of pop culture from film and video games to comics and anime. Bruno is one of Alma's triplets, and he gained the power of being able to see the future. Bruno's odd demeanor, affinity for rats, and often doomsaying visions had distinguished him as the "black sheep" of the Madrigals, resulting in his . Even if it wanted to, "Encanto" simply doesn't have the time to explain every little detail of its plot. Encanto Ending: Does Mirabel Have A Power Now? - Screen Rant Years ago, while fleeing from an armed conflict in Colombia, Alma Madrigal a.k.a. In Disney's Encanto, Mirabel Madrigal embarks on a journey for answers and faces many harsh realities. Things are kept especially opaque by the fact that the family spends the majority of the movie refusing to even discuss the threat. Because Mirabel has no direct expectations, she does everything she can for the Casita and her family even without being asked. Did UK Cineworld Chain Receive Wrong Version Of Mission Impossible 7? When looking through the lens of the theory, the Casita chose Mirabel not to have powers to teach a lesson to Abuela Alma, as she was becoming too focused on maintaining the miracle and not on how she was treating her family. These days, it feels like everyone's. Though Mirabel doesn't have powers, there may be a reason why. However, as the pressure to keep their Abuela happy pushes their minds into dark places, the magic begins to die, and the tensions rise, andaccording to a theory from Redditor Ishdakitty, Mirabel's lack of powers is a direct response to the pressure hurting her family. Mirabel was treated poorly by Alma throughout Encanto. Encanto: 10 Worst Things Abuela Did To Her Family, Ranked - CBR She's not stupid, she's just a kid. She always brings the right amount of humor and heart to the character. so, of course, siblings can have incredibly petty reasons to hate one another. Egon didn't abandon his family but still sent checks so they could get by or make sure that they were taken care of. Alma apologizes, and it doesn't matter that she has made Mirabel feel lesser for the last ten years. "Encanto" cuts from this moment straight to Mirabel leaving Bruno's room entirely, via the door. However, the vision is fluid and can be changed. Disney To put it simply/harshly, the theory argues that Abuela didn't really think Mirabel had a defining trait that could lead to a specific magical gift. He gets a prophecy of the casita being cracked, with Miarbel in the middle. I rarely say that an actors performance in a movie or show is perfect. Contributor Kate Snchez wrote a fantastic piece about this subject with more of a focus on Mirabel, so I want to talk about Bruno (no-no-no). Emailus. Warning: Contains spoilers for Encanto. He explained that he had the vision the night that Mirabel didn't get her gift, and knew that the family was in trouble. And if you're someone whose source of happiness, joy and comfort was in jeopardy, you'd react similarly if not worse. The oldest Madrigal triplet is Bruno, who has the ability to see into the future, but due to the fact that his prophecies are not always positive, he is seen as a blight and ostracized by the village and his family. This secrecy is eventually explained to spring from Alma's fear and trauma, which has been passed down to her children and grandchildren in complex ways. Her admittedly flawed way of thinking was born from a place of fear as the Casita represents the security given to her after her husband died. The magic manifested into an enchanted candle, the magic house, and the family receiving special abilities. so, after mirabel's gift ended the way it did, isabela would've had a front row seat to alma's resentment for mirabel developing and when alma criticised all of mirabel's actions, isa could've very easily internalised this cause and effect. Mirabel Madrigal | Encanto Wiki | Fandom Did Mirabel get her own room at the end? Everything Everywhere All at Once Gets Additional Content Rerelease, James Gunn Once Again Shocks World with Controversial Tweet, Julie Strain, Heavy Metal Queen of B-Movies, Has Died, The Ring, Ju-On and The Eternal Wrath of The Asian Ghost Woman, The Show Review: Alan Moore's First Film Far Funnier Than You Expect, When Star Lord's Mom Met Captain America- James Gunn Says It's Quill's Grandma, "Mission: Impossible": Pom Klementieff Cast in 7th and 8th Films, 'Captain Marvel': Slow to Start, But a Winner by the End [Review, No Spoilers], 5 New Posters and Promo Art for "Birds of Prey: And the Fantabulous Emancipation of One Harley Quinn", A Drug That Makes People Attractive is Explored in New Spiderhead Clip, Aliens Abducted My Parents Stars Forte & Mitchell on Comedy, Co-Stars, Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania Confirmed by Marvel Studios. the resentment turning into affection in the middle of a song, whilst very disney-esk, could serve as proof of this. In Disney's Encanto, Mirabel is the only child in the Family Madrigal without powers, and the movie may secretly reveal the true reason why. Of course, an Encanto sequel could change things in the future. The family blamed her and Isabela said she hated her. Alma refuses to even question the viability of the miracle that saved her and her loved ones, which causes, ironically, a rift between her and those she holds dear: One of her sons runs away for 10 years, Mirabel grows up feeling like an outcast, and everyone else feels terrified to ever express dissatisfaction or doubt. But at no point does anyone actually figure out or explain what, precisely, is menacing the candle, and why. They also reflect the resident's nature, and that of the supernatural gifts they receive. After Alma accused her of hurting the family, Mirabel thought that she would never be good enough. Why couldn't it have happened a little bit earlier, if it's capable of such tremendous feats? Nobody knows why the miracle candle didnt work for her, but she does all she can to help hold the family together.