Create your free profile and get access to exclusive content. The Attorney General's Office agreed with the suicide determination. That type of immunity protects public authorities from lawsuits stemming from discretional decision-making in their official capacity. Police publicly disputed the medical examiners findings and Osbourne later changed his ruling to suicide, with no explanation to the Greenbergs. A computer illustration showing two of Ellen Greenberg's knife wounds to the back of her neck and skull. Typically if a person is stabbing you, theyre not going to stab you several times superficially and then start to stab you deeper. Death of Ellen Greenberg - Generation Why Podcast . Podraza says new evidence including information from a deposition from the Medical Examiner's Office should be enough to change the ruling. MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Ellen Greenberg | Crime Junkie Podcast Ellen Rae Greenberg (June 23, 1983 - January 26, 2011) was a 27-year-old first grade teacher at Juniata Park Academy in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, Copyright 2023 WPVI-TV. The Greenbergs and their attorney, Joseph Podraza Jr., filed their lawsuit against the city in October 2019, seeking to have the manner of Ellens death changed back to homicide or undetermined, a move that would allow for an investigation to be reopened and pave the way for a possible wrongful-death or misconduct lawsuit against the city. Another rendering showing more than a dozen of Ellen Greenberg's stab wounds. After this, Samuel chose to keep his life private as he helped in investigations. We are all going to be there at some point, and while many of us do so peacefully. Detectives concluded her death was a suicide. Ellen Greenberg died on Jan. 26, 2011. Coincidentally, their former lawyer, Larry Krasner, had been sworn in as the District Attorney of Philadelphia. Suddenly, he stopped posting, and most fans thought he had taken a break. Investigators on scene treated her death as a suicide because the apartment door which Goldberg said he broke down was locked from the inside, there were no signs of an intruder, and Greenberg had no defensive wounds, police have said. Mara said in her one year of small talk with Greenberg, she never mentioned a boyfriend or a fiance. But after a half an hour or so at the gym, Sam returned to the couple's apartment to find the swing bolt latched. Lastly, there's a feeling that the 911 call by Ellie Greenberg's fianc was rehearsed and is being investigated. Justice for Ellen/Facebook. Michael Ruiz is a reporter for Fox News Digital. Marlon Osbourne, the medical examiner, ruled the death as a homic*de but later changed it to suic*de and closed the case. While the Office of Attorney General does not have an actual conflict in this matter, circumstances beyond our control have created the appearance of a conflict and our involvement is no longer serving one of the primary purposes of the District Attorney's original conflict referral. "At a minimum," the cause of death should have been "undetermined," D'Andrea said. (Tom Brennan). You should have a little empathy here.. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your devices and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. We didnt like what was happening, Joshua explained. The two women met back in April 2009 when Mara was moving in. There was no need for an ambulance she was already dead. Ellen Greenberg's 2011 Death To Be Re-Examined By Chester County DA This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. But weeks later, he changed her manner of death to suicide, with no explanation to Ellens parents, who learned about the reversal from media reports. He said that Ellens superficial stab wounds could be consistent with suicide. You could plainly see the nerves were severed, recalled Brennan. Ellen Greenberg, left, in an undated family photo (Greenberg family), ELLEN GREENBERG SUICIDE: PENNSYLVANIA COURT HEARS ARGUMENTS IN FAMILY'S BID TO OVERRULE MEDICAL EXAMINER. Ellen Greenberg's death was ruled homicide, then switched to suicide without explanation. She did not provide a timeline for the investigation's possible conclusion. However, there hasn't been any confirmation about these rumors, even though it's been a long time since the popular YouTuber uploaded a video. Lawyers on both sides of the appeal made their cases before a three-member panel of the Commonwealth court Tuesday, Joe Podraza, an attorney for Greenbergs parents, told Fox News Digital. Her students loved her, she seemed to have a supportive family, a loving fianc, and she was planning a weddingbut she had reportedly been suffering from work-related anxiety and had been "overwhelmed with her classroom work, according to the medical examiner's report. "[The] judges were well-prepared and versed about the issues," he said. Nothing was stolen from the apartment, which was locked from the inside. Another claim is that one of Ellen's stab wounds was in her heart, yet she was left-handed. Suicide Or Murder: What Happened to Ellen Greenberg? | Crime News Philly mayor under scrutiny as city resists push to reinvestigate Tom Brennan and Ellen Greenberg's parents break down fianc Sam Goldberg's 911 call the day he discovered Ellen Greenberg's body in 'Teacher Death Mystery: A Nancy Grace Investigation.'. Samuel Goldberg was the fianc of Ellen Greenberg, a schoolteacher who was found dead in their apartment. Sandee said she was in shock at the news:All I know is my world went dark, and I have no daughter, Sandee told producers. Who is Victor Oquendo's wife and what is his sexuality? Greenberg, 27, was found with fatal stab wounds to her chest at 6:30 p.m. on Wednesday night inside her Venice Lofts apartment on Flat Rock Road, just off of Main Street. Ellen Greenberg's family has long maintained that their daughter's death was a homicide, not a suicide. Greenburg's body was described as "flaccid" except for her hands, which were "slightly stiff" and "cool to the touch"; her front, torso, and back were still warm. Case and Ashley Reeve's condition today. Gallard says they will focus on the students in Greenbergs classroom and then visit each classroom in the school. Outside investigators said the damage shown to the lock on Greenberg's apartment door is inconsistent with the report it had been kicked in from the outside. Francis Atwoli Flies Wife Mary Kilobi in Chopper to Masai Mara for Her Birthday Celebration, Bernice Saroni Displays Gorgeous Living Room with Elegant Furniture, Portraits of Samidoh's Kids, Wilbroda Celebrates Son Xola on His 13th Birthday in Heartwarming Post: "Real Gentleman", Pastor Ezekiel Odero Brags He's Tough-Headed in Video with Pius Muiru's Son: "Uliza Shetani", Martha Karua, Juliani, Lillian Nganga Dazzle in Stylish Outfits at Boniface Mwangi's 40th Birthday Party. Samuel was returning from the gym and found the door locked. Earlier this month, the attorney generals spokesman released their latest findings to The Inquirer. (Tom Brennan, Greenberg family). Her parents are fighting to take their civil suit to trial. There are claims that there was no bleeding from her 20 stab wounds. Another oddity jumped out at McDonald: Ellen had been stabbed through her clothing, something that also isnt often indicative of suicide. The one thing that makes Ellens death controversial is that the medical examiner initially ruled as homic*de and then changed it to suic*de after receiving pressure from the police. A Philly teacher's brutal stabbing has experts at odds: Was it a Still, Shapiro says that he is open to exploring new evidence if it is presented. Goldberg graduated from Temple University and worked in Stamford, Conn., as a producer for NBC Sports. The whole thing, it just didn't make sense. ", Michael Ruiz is a reporter for Fox News Digital. Simpsons defense, both authored independent reports questioning the manner of Ellens death. She chickened out [of getting her ears pierced]she didn't like pain, her own pain, said Joshua. In court Tuesday, Diffily said the Greenbergs were asking for a sea change in the law and argued if the case were to proceed, it would open the floodgates for other lawsuits. SCROLL TO SEE IMAGES FROM THE AUTOPSY REPORT: Another rendering showing more than a dozen of Ellen Greenberg's stab wounds. Ellen Greenberg case: New details from civil suit - Inquirer.com The city argues that under the law, a medical examiners opinion cant be challenged, but Podraza believes testimony from depositions in the civil suit necessitate the ruling be changed. Right: Ellen and then-fiance Sam Goldberg. A younger Ellen Greenberg smiles in an undated photo provided by her childhood friend and Penn State classmate. Police deemed Ellen's death a suicide before an autopsy was performed. Hopeful, the family approached him to re-open the investigation into their daughters death, but Krasner referred the case to the State Attorney Generals Office so as to avoidthe appearance of a conflict of interest. And Ellens family also corroborated this, telling police Goldberg was a fine, young man.". March 24, 2022 When we found out certain facts along the wayshe had wounds on her back. He also noted the deeper stab wounds, the number of punctures, and a gash that was also found on Ellens forehead complicated the case. She had no apparent defensive wounds,and her apartment was locked from the inside. The first lawsuit is seeking to have her cause of death revised from suicide to homicide or undecided. Were asking to change the manner of death and open a new investigation with impartial people and an impartial prosecutor, Joshua Greenberg said. They used to bump into each other on numerous occasions in the halls, in the parking lot and in the elevator of their building. A civil suit reveals new details in the case of Ellen Greenberg, whose As a result, we believe it is in the best interest of the public for this case to be referred to another office. Our office has stated that if and when new evidence was brought forward, we would thoroughly review it. Mom Is Fatally Shot by Retired Police Officer Ex-Boyfriend, Who Then Turns Gun on Himself. Her parents are fighting to take their civil suit to trial. Even though Ellen's wounds appeared difficult for her to have inflicted on herself, policecould find no signs of someone else being in the apartment, according to Accident, Suicide or Murder., After Ellen's autopsy,however,the medical examiner attributed her death to homicide, due to the nature of her wounds.