James Malone is one of the most eloquent and revolutionary guitarists I've ever heard in death metal, that's a fact. Growing up in the old Soviet Union I remember getting up in the morning listening to the radio station my family liked. In my opinion the second track "Maddening Disdain" is the stand out track of this album for containing a great amount of catchy thrash style riffs and tons of vocal hooks in James Malone's Dimmu Borgir style voice. The drumming, as well, is more acoustic sounding and a hell of a lot less triggered sounding than every subsequent album. Specifically, he takes the juicier parts from renowned composers like Marios Iliopoulos of Nightrage and the Svensson/Bjrler/Larsson intersections of At The Gates, then reinvigorates those ideas with a much flashier sense of melodic play that would sit comfortably on solo guitarist material if it weren't attached so firmly to the notion of melodeath riffing and harmony. Arsis is quite the competent band, musically, and you'll likely have a difficult time finding someone who finds something to dislike about the musical qualities in the band's music. In addition to James the other member of Arsis who is more or less a staple of the band is the drummer on this album Mike Van Dyne who had quit the band to finish college and get a degree but now he is back with Arsis and there new album "Starve for the Devil" due out in february 2010 is shaping up to be a kickass death metal album. Another aspect of the album I quite like is the production. In fact, this cd gets the metalhead's attention for that matter: he is completely unique. Album Rating: 2.0The band is good enough. Released March 30, 2004. Multi-instrumental talent, and showing that skill in your own album that will soon become a milestone, is something I now hold in high regard. Scrobbling is when Last.fm tracks the music you listen to and automatically adds it to your music profile. This guy is giving a performance of a lifetime on that album. Even the vocals change slightly from song to song. If you're lucky enough to find this in your local record shop, do no hesitate to pick it up, as it is definitely a worthy investment. A Diamond For Disease is a far better listen. For a debut album, the production is very high quality, yet not in an annoying way; the guitars are crunchy yet piercing and the drums are crushing. The Face Of My Innocence, Maddening Disdain, Seven Whispers Fell Silent. James Malone succeeds here because he sticks with riffs that essentially work; someone more familiar with their later stuff may note that it is much simpler than later works. You may also need to save a bit of extra cash to spend on neck surgery after all the headbanging that awaits you. This album is complex. Has already been listened to a great many times. If there is one criticism of instrumentation, it is that the bass is mostly inaudible, but that is pretty much a given at this point in metal. Seven Whispers Fell Silent 4. I could mention Carcass, Susperia, Dismember influences as well. The lyrics and songs are all remarkable, with its unique moments which transform them into a work of punishing and fine art. Malone's bass playing is strong and gives the album a more bombastic kind of feel. This is like a quasi-arbitrary implementation of the early 2000's melo-death writing protocol, organized in a way that some songs (not many) may get away with earning a distinct identity, but fall short of granting enough significance to those identities. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. The songs themselves seem to have their own mini-movements within. Eh. It's Thor everytime! Drumming is certainly adequate as well. Released 30 March 2004 on Willowtip (catalog no. "The sadistic Motives Behind Bereavement Letter". Malone's vocals have just that same impulsive bloodthirst that Tomas Lindberg produces at his best, along with a bit of Chance Garnette's rasp, Van Dyne's drumming is as tight as I wish I could sleep, and the production is just so - an inch to either side and it would sound too chaotic or too clean. The band genre is evidently melodic death BUT there is also another genre that is reflected through their intense and numerous riffs and that style is the very essence of American underground music: thrash metal. A Celebration of Guilt Arsis. With A Celebration of Guilt, you enter a battlefield and kill everything in your way without looking back, without remorse. The guitar player has a knack for writing high quality riffs, he can shred like a god, and he is a rather fine singer to boot. learn more, Sell directly to your fans with total control over your music and pricing. Michael Van Dyne on drums effortlessly switches from double bass to fast blasting (Maddening Disdain). Melody is used very precisely by Arsis - while it is common for melodic death metal bands to let the music be dominated by simple harmonies of thirds, string skipping riffs, and add chords, Arsis blend them together to the point where one never dominates a song, and rarely a section. 2. Because after the arrival of the Triumvirate of the genre that is Dark Tranquillity, In Flames and At the Gates, all the following wannabe bands thought that in order to be melodic you had to have acoustic guitar parts. Although Arsis could never top this album with their subsequent followups, A Celebration of Guilt will serve as the album that all future albums by the band would be judged by. March 9, 2004 13 Songs, 50 minutes 2015 Willowtip Records. Start the wiki. Many solos, mostly short but still very fast-paced, lots of tapping and all that. Arsis has a thrash influence, the sound, the solos; some of the songwriting in this album could be linked to the more American sounding metal. On the drumming side of things Van Dyne performs thrash metal-style double bass drumming in addition to black metal style blast beats with little to no error. That's because Malone was smart enough to keep this uncluttered, with just enough technicality to turn ordinary melodeath into the crushing and stomping metal maelstrom that it is. Theyre from the States. :p 2:56. The Sadistic Motives Behind Bereavement Letters has Gothenburg, Dark Tranquillity Skydancer-era leads, and Carnal Ways to Recreate the Heart is blast&tremolo black harmonies with an appropriately higher pitched vocals. The only minor criticism I'd care to mention (besides the slight excess in length) regards the fairly abrupt curtailing of a few songs, especially obvious when 'Wholly Night' closes proceedings all of a sudden with what feels like about 3 seconds of fade-out. We cannot do much about this right now; you must turn off your VPN to continue using the site. There is no point on the album where the band lets up. In hindsight it's fair to say those years were the tipping point between bands that were of the old death metal guard, and the deathcore scene that was close to follow. (Required), You can request being unblocked by clicking. MOSH 312 CD; CD). This is how Melodic Death Metal should be played: fast, agile, elegant and aggressive and destructive. The album was released March 30, 2004 in North America by Willowtip and on July 11, 2005 in Europe via Earache Records. Excellent guitar playing skill is what creates these awesome melodies. Try a different filter or a new search keyword. But we can't forget the melodic side of Arsis, for it too makes the listener quite aware. Later in the song, that chunky groove section punctuated by the pinch harmonic sounds awfully close to what loads of bands were doing at the time, particularly the song 'Meticulous Invagination' by Aborted. They really set a standard so high that Malone and co. wouldn't have a chance of ever topping this. Let me rectify that by stating just how good he is. This isn't even mildly entertained by the thought. Veil of Mourning Black. The bring a view of melodic death that has never been done before. Arsis were like this excellent learner at school, but who couldn't for the life of him make anything creative for himself. I digress. Nice work, you nailed it, rating and all. Audio CD, Deluxe Edition, Original recording reissued, August 9, 2011, Reviewed in the United States on March 3, 2022. The music is lightning fast, fucking brutal, and tech enough to make Necrophagist sweat. At some points it can be hard to distinguish between songs, but they're all good enough that it isn't an issue. classic Review by Thor USER ( 73 Reviews) February 20th, 2006 | 309 replies Release Date: 2004 | Tracklist Review Summary: A Celebration of Guilt is the perfect combination of melody, technicality, catchiness and brutality. Malone continued to release albums and tour under the Arsis banner with several different lineups through the years, and also released music with Necromancing The Stone and Sacrifixx. The performing band members thoroughly incorporate their influences in the entire record while sounding unique. But there are a hand full of great melodic death metal bands from the US like The Absence, Vehemance and my favorite melodic death metal band of all time Arsis. We hope to eventually work on a solution for this when we have the resources to do so. However, Arsis, nearly ten years after the release of The Gallery and Whoracle proved all these inbred followers that passion, not imitation is the key. The guitars are where the music really shines. As it stands, the vocals are mid-range growls, tremolo is present (but used sparingly), the drums are fast but not outright blasting and so, melodic death metal it is. Home Melodic aggressive death/thrash/blackened metal. Tracks such as "Maddening Disdain", "Return" and "The Sadistic Motives Behind Be" show Arsis at their absolute finest. Catchy parts recur and will be remembered before the section is over, and certainly before the song is over. The Face Of My Innocence 2. Okay, now I have to say that I took a couple of days to realise what was in front of me. By not picking this up you are just simply missing out on a great album. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations. [quote=Ben]SON OF A BITCH :MAD:[/quote]Hehe, I don't think :mad: works with the cap locks. You'll need to disable 'The Human Web' functionality entirely. This very difference gives the album a level of intensity we never see in any Swedish or Norwegian melodic death bands. So, the question: was A Celebration of Guilt the harbinger of a new era for melodic death metal? Unable to add item to List. And, even though the blade tips (metal styles) were all different in shape, my brain has been sufficiently minced and pulverized. As is the drumming of Van Dyne; how it is absolutely refreshing to here a drummer whose double bass is not triggered in technical metal, and whose chops, rolls, blasts, fills are precise and mix very well with the technical and [at times] Scandinavian-esque overtone of melody that Arsis are best known for. That's it. This band manages to bring together everything that I could possibly want in a melodic death band. INCINERATE IN A HELL COMPLETELY DEVOID OF ALL FEMALES FOR THAT! Is A Celebration of Guilt that good? Close. We got besides Arsis, such good bands that support the style like: Allegaeon, Bloodshot Dawn and Quo vadis. You can tell this man is enraged, frustrated and truly feeling his songs of hatred, disillusion and wrath. It also analyzed reviews to verify trustworthiness. Arsis is a two man band from the USA whom I would classify as melodic death metal, and as far as melodic death metal goes, A Celebration of Guilt is easily one of the finest recordings of the entire genre. Your computer may be infected with malware or spyware that makes automated requests to our server and causes problems. Standout tracks: Their throttle is on full all the time. The melodies don't wander too much. Featured peformers: James Malone (guitar, bass, vocals), Michael Van Dyne (drums), Mark Riddick (artwork). Quite simply, the guitar playing here is incredible. Songs such as Maddening Disdain and Seven Whispers Fell Silent both stress this element in their respective structures and both succeed in drawing listeners in through their shockingly infectious combination of aggression and melody. Stylistically, it's a blend of some styles - technical death metal, melodic death metal, and neo-thrash - that are often complacent and self-indulging, focusing on their defining traits rather than making good music. Carnal Ways To Recreate The Heart 8. Some embrace it and enjoy hearing catchy melodies. I'm not really headbanging while I listen to this album, more dancing on my chair as these 11 songs shred and thrash and caterwaul around me, each movement paying off when the next begins and refreshing the experience way before it becomes dull. Get a new vocalist, and this would be one of the best American metal bands today. Increble precio para ser la edicin especial de este gran lbum de death metal, Reviewed in Germany on October 8, 2013. Alternately, perhaps A Celebration of Guilt was just really fucking good and - for many - that was enough. Arsis keeps the speed at maximum for basically the whole album, without pause to give you a break. Although i would give this 4.5, because i think that ADFD is a step up musicially in both song writing and general brutality, this album is brilliant. If you like extreme metal you may get your fix by digesting all of its ingredients separately. Featured peformers: James Malone (guitar, bass, vocals), Michael Van Dyne (drums), Mark Riddick (artwork). Album Rating: 4.0excellent album. However, Arsis, nearly ten years after the release of The Gallery and Whoracle proved all these inbred followers that passion, not imitation is the key. The musicianship is top notch for a debut. Arsis - Celebration Of Guilt,A [Deluxe] - Amazon.com Music CDs & Vinyl Metal Death Metal Have one to sell? Although the technical ability here is high, there is little flashiness evident in the playing. So Arsis plays with more intensity, without slowing down and with a very high level of melody. With A Celebration of Guilt, you enter a battlefield and kill everything in your way without looking back, without remorse. When combined with the excellent performances and razor-sharp songwriting, this really becomes irresistible to metalheads of several persuasions and listens just as well a pretty massive 17 years later. This is not lamely done european melodeath, this is crushing american death metal that happens to be melodic. It's not just the same brutal shit or that melodic death metal sound with no identity at all. The opening track "The Face of My Innocence" its an anthem to the band and opens the album in no better way. There are tons of hooks which work into the songs without an overtly pop-ish sound, but they don't give up any of the fierce metallic sound. The high growls that fill each song are well-executed and don't sound whiny, which seems to be the standard in modern metal. In terms of sound, I would classify Arsis as an admixture of different death metal styles, with melodic and technical parts in various combinations. Tech heads will find plenty of mind-boggling instrumentals to marvel at. On many songs the drumbeat patterns often change without letting the listener settle in (Seven Whispers Fell Silent, Wholly Night). Classic not because only of its unique usage of melody, but also because they finally gave a shot of much needed brutal adrenaline into the veins of Melodic Death Metal. You might have the Ghostery extension installed. think again. In place of that is a collection of good to brilliant riffs, as well as good to brilliant songs. Fette Riffs, geile Melodien, unglaubliche Kunstfertigkeit an den Instrumentenso muss das sein !!! Recall that Arsis released their debut album in 2004, a year that reminds me of all that was played out in metal; trad styles mostly scorned, thrash dead and not yet back(! Riffs vary in sonic texture, often times with consistent shifts in direction or feel. To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we dont use a simple average. Arsis - A Celebration Of Guilt Artist: Arsis Release: A Celebration Of Guilt 1. It's a great album, a classic that came out of the cuts and surprised everybody. The Sadistic Motives Behind Bereavement Letters, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License. He often uses multiple guitar layering to create the most incredible guitar harmonies as well. They COMPLETELY kill everything that makes the band good, and makes it unlistenable. Album Rating: 5.0If you're looking into more metal then I would strongly advise that you check them out. Clicking on the affiliate links above may result in this site earning a commission on purchases. Memorable could be easily his second name, because the drums work not only in being complex and to mark the tempo, but participates as any other instrument, almost creating melodies with the music. Most importantly, it leaves behind many of the undesirable and stagnant traits of the styles that are blended so well. Admittedly, I didn't know how good I was going to call this before I started writing, and in the process I've realized that almost everything went right for Arsis with A Celebration of Guilt. One can point to any track, whether it be the opener, Face of My Innocence, Return, or Looking for Nothing, and find the uncontested amounts of brutality that one would expect from in a death metal band. No filler here. The guy is a monster, playing and developing a amount of unique and intricated riffs (and not to mention the monstrous solos), while managing to execute an extremely difficult vocal, a total singular one that acutes to melodic death, but with a more dark and morbid touch, not taking influences of the typical american screamo (like a lot of melodic death bands that come from the US does). The production is balanced and it is well mixed, but not polished. The guitar play of Malone displays a perfect amount of melody to compensate the technical aspect of the music. The drumming by Michael VanDyne on this album is shockingly accurate. The vocals seem like they would not be out of place in a black metal band such as Naglfar, Immortal, and maybe even Dissection. The vocals are another tool used to insert rhythmic hooks, providing entirely different rhythmic patterns from the instruments, something uncommon in bands where an instrumentalist handles vocals. 1. not exactly my style, but I recognize the skill. I can't comprehend how the vocals can ruin the album, they're pretty much just standard raspy screaming. And in my opinion again, "Wholly Night" is just a fuckin tremendous masterpiece of melodic death metal, the best song in the album. Enter Arsis, the American melodic death phenominon that completely dominates anything relating to melodic death metal. Every song has at least one riff that will get stuck in the listeners head for at least a couple of days and although treading the known path of melodic death, he still shows us new ways of walking it. 11 tracks (44:27). It is the fusion of technicality and melody that is written proportionately, and without abuse. Our terms of service forbid this. Its original, its different, its music for headbanger's ears. Personally, I'd been searching for an album like this for a long time; and when I finally stumbled across this recently, I was very satisfied. Everything is quite well put together and easy to hear, whether it be the shrieks and growls of James Malone, the wailing harmonies, or the ferocious drumming of Mike van Dyne. One part of Arsis's intensity definitely relates to speed, because sections come and go extremely rapidly, exaggerating the effect by not always following regular structures, even if repetition is used to its fullest potential in certain songs. I will be sure to do so, if I can find this. The early 2000's were a bit of a time of confusion for metal, wasn't it. Needless to say many of the lyrics in Arsis songs deal with his own problems in life. The drums flow beautifully and have a pristine accuracy. Overall I gave this album a perfect score because this album changed the way I look at the whole genre of death metal and completely changed the way I write music and I hope people who read this review go buy the album and have it effect them the way it did me. Artist: Arsis: Type: Album: Released: 2005: RYM Rating: 4.00 . The intensity I'm after revolves around a sort of momentum that need not be ceaseless, instead sort of lurching its way into the same primal brain cavity that makes humans dance even when entirely ignorant of the song that's playing, and that's what Arsis give me. or perhaps Heartwork-era Carcass or the last two Death albums. [5], "ARSIS - A Celebration Of Guilt To Be Reissued With Bonus Material", "Arsis - A Celebration of Guilt (album review)", "Releases > Arsis - A Celebration Of Guilt Deluxe Limited Gatefold Lp + Bonus 7", "Releases > Arsis - A Celebration Of Guilt (Slipcase Reissue)", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=A_Celebration_of_Guilt&oldid=1150661930, "The Sadistic Motives Behind Bereavement Letters", This page was last edited on 19 April 2023, at 11:50. The level of energy displayed in the lead-guitar and drums is at maximum, keeping you on the edge of your seat the whole time. I will begin this review by stating that Arsis A Celebration of Guilt is the best debut album that I have heard. The amount of violence and raw aggression displayed on A Celebration of Guilt far surpasses that of most albums recorded after the early '90s. However, the vocals are raspy black-metal style, so that will throw you for a loop. There is but one downside to the high level of quality of this music: there is simply no way it can be topped by the band, ever. Speaking of guitar play, Malone is the only guitarist which means that the twin guitar solos is basically Malone trading solos with himself. I love the kick drums too, how real they are instead of all triggery. My highlights of the album are The Face of My Innocence, Maddening Disdain, Worship Depraved and Wholly Night. Willowtip deserves all kinds of credit for discovering Arsis. Often though, in their defense, they back this up with a heavy groove that retrieves a bit of weight, sometimes spirited and with good drive. Top subscription boxes right to your door, 1996-2023, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates, Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon. Arsis' can best be described using the term extreme metal. This guy never gets repetitive or bland with his drumming and easily hold together that forceful punch behind the music. A Celebration of Guilt Tracklist. There's much more melody here than on many tech-death albums, though; Malone favors epic choruses and fleet, slick solos, both of which are heard in abundance on songs like album opener "The Face of My Innocence" and "Maddening Disdain," the latter of which is built around a riff that wouldn't sound out of place on a Megadeth album. I never could figure out how that was a compliment its a hair away from saying the musics middle-of-the-road or pedestrian. [+] The full-length debut by Virginia-based technical death metal group Arsis is actually a duo recording -- bandleader James Malone plays guitar and bass and sings, supported by drummer Michael Van Dyne. The violent nature of both genres (as well as in death metal, obviously) plays quite a prominent role in the foundation of the music on A Celebration of Guilt, yet never do these chaotic overtones feel excessive or unneeded. Each movement has their own identity, which may be a single riff or a collection thereof. Considering the heaviness of the album, it's quite amazing how guitarist/vocalist/bassist James Malone manages to incorporate any melody into the music. Genres: Melodic Death Metal, Technical Death Metal. [3], Following its release, it was met with very favorable reviews by online publications such as AllMusic,[1] Metal Storm,[4] and Sputnikmusic.